3
|
PuertoRican   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:03. Posts 13044 | | |
Even though I wanted Neil Magny to win, I thought he lost that fight.
With the new rules, people like Hendricks won't go far because LnP won't be scored as highly. |
|
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 04:04. Posts 2440 | | |
Well the takedown in round 3 took place with roughly 1 min to go if i remember correct, megny clearly won the standup until sthis point, imo. |
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 04:05. Posts 2440 | | |
|
|
1
|
iakim322   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:06. Posts 1335 | | |
Hendricks did absolutely nothing with his one takedown in Rd 1. Thought it should ideally have been scored 10-10 but since judges don't do that, glad they gave it to magny |
|
|
1
|
soberstone   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:07. Posts 2662 | | |
| On December 31 2016 03:03 ERASA wrote:
the thing with hendricks is, he takes people down does almost nothing and expects to win, guess if thats his gameplan he should stick to wrestling...
Btw where is hendricks' power...? He used to knock people out all the time... |
I agree, I think his style of fighting is terrible to watch and lame. Thing is, Magny didn't do anything for 90 percent of the fight accept try to get up and fail.
I honestly think people are just scoring it the way they want to because of Johnnys personality / awful boring style instead of the way it should be objectively based on how 99 percent of MMA has been scored since it's inception. But I admit I myself am biased. |
|
| Last edit: 31/12/2016 04:10 |
|
|
1
|
Floofy   Canada. Dec 31 2016 04:09. Posts 8708 | | |
| On December 31 2016 02:59 soberstone wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 31 2016 02:58 ERASA wrote:
1 and 3 Magny.. i might be biased though... |
All 3 judges scored it the way you did. But I think that's insane.
|
Round 2 goes to Hendricks, everyone agrees on this.
Round 3 i actually think i agree with judges. Even tho Hendricks was in control most of the round, he did jack shit.
SS were 30 vs 6 in favor of Magny.
Magny also came pretty close to stopping the fight, and he did a good sub attempt.
Round 1 should be the deciding round. I'm surprised all 3 judges gave it to magny. You could argue Magny did more damage and was more dangerous, but if we go by current judging rules, i believe it should go to hendricks. |
|
james9994: make note dont play against floofy, ;( | |
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 04:09. Posts 2440 | | |
No... he was actually pretty active with strikes from his back and had two triangles... i would argue he did more from bottom than hendricks from the top... |
|
|
1
|
soberstone   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:12. Posts 2662 | | |
Yah Floofy basically your last sentence is my point. Since when is lying on a guy for 3 rounds not a gay win. Quite a huge shift in judging philosophy from the norm. |
|
|
1
|
soberstone   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:12. Posts 2662 | | |
|
|
1
|
Floofy   Canada. Dec 31 2016 04:17. Posts 8708 | | |
| On December 31 2016 03:12 soberstone wrote:
Yah Floofy basically your last sentence is my point. Since when is lying on a guy for 3 rounds not a gay win. Quite a huge shift in judging philosophy from the norm. |
http://mmadecisions.com/decision/7612/Neil-Magny-vs-Johny-Hendricks
ok now i'm even more surprised. This site does agree with judges. |
|
james9994: make note dont play against floofy, ;( | |
|
|
1
|
Montrachet   Canada. Dec 31 2016 04:22. Posts 120 | | |
Holly crap Borg is impressive on the ground. |
|
|
5
|
Nazgul   Netherlands. Dec 31 2016 04:31. Posts 7080 | | |
This is the type of fight for Smolka that shortens your career. |
|
You almost twin-caracked his AK - JonnyCosmo | |
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 04:36. Posts 2440 | | |
|
|
3
|
PuertoRican   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:36. Posts 13044 | | |
Wow...
Ray Borg looked so amazing with his grappling against a good grappler... |
|
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 04:37. Posts 2440 | | |
30-26? Thats aggressive... |
|
|
1
|
soberstone   United States. Dec 31 2016 04:37. Posts 2662 | | |
^^ Shows how good Scoggins is. Wish he could have made weight at '25 still, he would have been the first legit challenger to DJ. |
|
|
1
|
Montrachet   Canada. Dec 31 2016 05:06. Posts 120 | | |
Well, how do you score that kind of fight? |
|
|
1
|
ERASA   Germany. Dec 31 2016 05:09. Posts 2440 | | |
bleh.. tarec i guess.. 30-27 or 29-28 imo |
|
|
3
|
PuertoRican   United States. Dec 31 2016 05:10. Posts 13044 | | |
Close fight between Saff and Kim.
I give R1 to Saff. Rounds 2 and 3 to Kim.
Kim 2-1, imo. |
|
|
|
5
|
Nazgul   Netherlands. Dec 31 2016 05:10. Posts 7080 | | |
I had it 29-28 for Stungun too although I could see it the other way around. Whatever referee scored it 30-27 Saffiedine didn't have his glasses on in the third round. |
|
You almost twin-caracked his AK - JonnyCosmo | |
|
|
|